Gone With “What” Wind is another riff-based composition – a typical
blues by the sextet with very good solos by Charlie Christian; his solos are
about as blue as you can get at this tempo. The tune has nothing to do with
the immensely popular movie that had just been released a couple of months
earlier, other than to capitalize on the title. Six versions of this tune
were recorded: four with the sextet, one with a quintet, and one with the
February 7, 1940 WCO 46495 A
An assiduous day at the Columbia recording studios: following the Metronome
All Stars session, the Goodman band recorded three selections before the
sextet gathered to record two tunes (Till Tom Special was the first) with Count Basie invited to the piano
bench in Johnny Guarnieri’s stead and Charlie Christian and Lionel Hampton stepping up
to their usual posts.
On this initial take, Charles plays some untypical phrases across mm 5 and 6, and again on
first half of bar 7. After the guitar solo, we hear wonderful CC comping on
following 4 choruses, especially behind the vibes solo. Charles’ first set
of riffs is reminiscent of the 4-bar break introduced on the studio version
of AC-DC Current a month and a half earlier.
February 7, 1940 WCO 46495 B (master take)
With Basie still on piano and Hampton on vibes, this master take is taken at
a more relaxed tempo than on the previous take.
Interesting play of repeated ♭7/13 (F/E) on the
G7 sequence at mm 9-10 of
the guitar solo. Also note the two pre-bent notes on the 10th fret at bar
12. To complement the previous G7 sequence, we get a less elaborate
cluster on the F7 across mm 4-5 of the second chorus. After the guitar solo,
CC adds his very special touch of impetus with impromptu riffing behind the
vibes solo; he goes into straight comping on clarinet solo.
March 19, 1940 “The Cocoanut Grove” Ambassador
After the February 7th studio recording session, the band went on an
unrecorded 3-week tour to Pittsburgh, Indianapolis and Chicago, then took a
2½-week break before heading to the West Coast to begin a 6-week engagement
at The Cocoanut Grove where the very first tune the sextet recorded was Gone
With “What” Wind. Guarnieri was back in his piano chair and Hampton was
still on vibes.
On his solo, Charles hints at blues stuff at bars 6-7, then gets much
bluesier at mm 9-10 vexing the ninth of the
dom7. On his second chorus, he
uses a lot of vertical fretwork to make his familiar lines sound even blue-er
April 6, 1940 “The Cocoanut Grove” Ambassador
Still at “The Cocoanut Grove” with the same pianist and vibist, but at an
even faster clip.
Charles’ solo: Crossing mm 4 & 5 we get a hint of the cascading riffs
forthcoming in the first set of riffs after the solos. At bar 4 of the
second chorus, Charles starts a four-bar sequence that he more often used on
the bridge of a standard tune, then ends the run on mm 7-8 with another
example of his clever use of the sustained open string. The last four bars
of the solo are an abbreviated repeat of his last four-bars of the first
chorus in the master take of this tune two months earlier.
November 4, 1940 Democratic Presidential Campaign Rally, MSG
Co-composer, Basie, is once again on piano. The band had taken a three-month summer break after their West Coast tour
and was still in the process of getting re-established when this gig
presented itself for the ad-hoc quintet consisting of CC, BG and most of the Basie
rhythm section – Basie, Page, Jones – all five had participated in the renowned
octet rehearsal session at the Columbia studios a week earlier on 28
October. The piece is played at a slower tempo than on prior sessions.
As on the master take we again get the repeated ♭7/13 (F/E) sequence on the
G7 at mm 9-10 on the guitar solo. On the second chorus we get some more
vertical blues-work (as on 19 March) up and down on one string.
On this version of Gone With “What” Wind, Charles continues to riff for
eight more bars after the usual three shout choruses – an additional bonus
for the CC fan.
This political rally was held the day before Election Day in support of the
President’s re-election. Although FDR had addressed the rally at
Madison Square Garden on 28 October, he was not in attendance at this MSG
rally but he did get the opportunity to shake CC’s hand on another occasion.
February 19, 1941 “America in Swingtime”
This final version of Gone With “What” Wind is from the “America in
Swingtime” radio broadcast which had not been publicly available since its
original broadcast in 1941 – it was finally released in 2001 on the Encore
label, the only CC tune from that broadcast. Slower tempo again; Guarnieri
is back on piano, Cootie on trumpet, Tough on drums – this is the later
septet now. Auld is here but doesn’t solo on this tune.
Charles starts out very laid-bad, plays some standard lines until bar 8
where he gets really funky. The second chorus starts out with a
C6/9 including a
♭3, transitions with an
Fm6 into an elegant
run (C/C13/F9) normally found on
a non-blues tune. Still on the F7 section, Charles throws in a quick
♭7, 9, 13 arpeggio in bar 6 before leveling off into the
C where he stays
(except for an F7 for a couple of beats) till the end of his solo. Measure 9
of the second chorus has a sequence that mimics the repeated
found on some of the other versions of this tune but these are just
with the 3 moving up chromatically to the
As on the previous version, this one also has guitar riffs on the last
chorus – this time for the entire chorus.